Skip to main content

Table 1 Two-Way (batch and gender) ANOVA estimates of batch effects: Ref-mean, mean of BC males of Batch 1 (n=22)

From: Trypanotolerance in N’Dama x Boran crosses under natural trypanosome challenge: effect of test-year environment, gender, and breed composition

Trait

Ref-mean1

Actual trait mean values by batch2

S3

Mean All4

CV -Batch (%)5

CV-within (%)6

1

2

3

4

5

6

WIC

60.32

55.57

55.90

57.43

53.37

34.13

43.62

 

50.00

18.43

51.50

STR

20.05

19.36

18.40

18.18

16.18

8.05

18.58

***

16.46

25.84

72.40

STRTV

15.77

15.43

14.42

13.15

11.48

5.45

15.44

***

12.56

30.24

81.80

STRTC

4.27

3.93

3.98

5.03

4.70

2.60

3.14

 

3.90

23.49

61.30

TPS

50.05

47.70

51.31

37.25

29.80

16.13

41.85

***

37.34

34.50

93.20

MPAR

2.50

2.46

2.79

2.05

1.84

2.00

2.25

***

2.27

21.62

54.20

%PARD

0.33

0.40

0.31

0.29

0.33

0.15

0.45

***

0.32

31.35

94.10

NINF

5.46

4.56

4.14

4.32

3.98

3.57

4.01

***

4.10

8.23

44.40

NT

5.32

4.36

4.05

4.92

4.53

4.38

4.67

 

4.49

6.64

27.30

NTI

2.82

1.95

2.22

2.80

2.34

2.23

2.02

**

2.26

13.28

33.30

NIT

0.72

0.74

0.79

0.73

0.77

0.32

0.74

***

0.68

25.90

68.50

MNT

0.09

0.10

0.06

0.07

0.06

0.17

0.10

***

0.09

44.08

119.20

MNT1

0.05

0.03

0.03

0.04

0.03

0.07

0.04

**

0.04

39.82

96.40

DF1

14.27

14.23

15.21

28.86

26.59

24.38

15.40

***

20.78

31.54

70.20

DT1

18.68

23.50

35.41

29.62

68.18

25.34

30.23

***

35.38

46.92

143.20

DC1A

32.96

37.72

51.00

58.79

96.44

51.39

45.17

***

56.75

36.43

113.40

DF2

31.46

37.51

23.73

35.65

57.53

40.13

29.27

***

37.30

31.00

93.10

DCIB

50.14

61.05

55.43

61.12

129.14

66.71

59.65

***

72.18

38.98

112.30

DT2

33.19

42.24

57.32

51.99

33.82

8.01

17.78

***

35.19

54.88

146.40

DC2A

64.52

77.36

79.76

87.79

95.98

47.51

49.63

**

73.00

27.45

68.40

DC12

97.86

113.48

122.16

145.41

195.68

97.73

95.03

***

128.25

29.45

80.10

PCI

31.12

32.34

29.72

36.61

29.55

31.84

30.93

***

31.83

8.14

22.30

MPC

24.10

24.48

24.50

25.01

25.07

22.54

24.22

***

24.30

3.81

10.50

MXPC

33.14

33.41

34.42

35.45

33.45

29.73

35.93

***

33.73

6.56

18.40

MNPC

15.64

16.04

15.48

14.84

16.05

15.49

15.54

 

15.57

2.87

7.80

PCSR

30.32

30.59

32.51

29.63

29.27

25.51

35.24

 

30.46

10.76

32.00

PCF1

26.18

26.27

28.33

23.44

29.05

22.58

30.93

***

26.77

12.26

31.20

PCT1

17.46

17.56

16.63

15.79

17.57

18.50

17.30

***

17.22

5.37

15.80

PCF2

25.46

24.74

25.33

25.79

27.01

22.91

25.74

**

25.25

5.41

16.10

PCT2

17.38

17.35

16.40

17.18

18.59

18.17

17.69

*

17.57

4.39

12.50

PCIF1

−4.94

−6.07

−1.39

−13.17

−0.51

−10.46

0.01

***

−5.26

105.94

259.60

PCF1T1

−8.73

−8.70

−11.31

−7.32

−11.65

−3.86

−13.64

***

−9.42

37.44

103.80

PCIT1

−13.66

−14.78

−12.87

−20.78

−11.66

−14.32

−13.63

***

−14.67

21.73

63.00

PCT1F2

8.00

7.33

8.70

10.00

9.25

4.54

8.15

*

8.00

24.05

67.30

WTI

204.32

194.86

196.58

167.93

157.03

150.34

143.66

***

168.40

13.44

35.70

MWT

201.49

188.40

198.00

199.11

167.79

153.95

164.51

***

178.63

10.67

3.00

MXWT

235.82

217.73

230.73

235.31

195.19

176.42

195.99

***

208.56

11.06

3.00

MNWT

171.09

161.86

166.67

161.32

138.94

133.73

130.77

***

148.88

10.82

3.00

WTF1

191.84

181.36

182.72

181.81

150.26

151.08

152.56

***

166.63

10.09

2.00

WTT1

178.09

167.19

175.67

167.48

174.40

135.07

158.70

***

163.08

9.20

3.00

WTF2

181.82

176.73

191.84

176.97

167.09

150.66

146.29

***

168.26

10.28

3.00

WTE

231.19

215.90

201.50

197.16

164.16

140.12

168.33

**

186.92

2.88

22.20

WTIF1

−9.78

−13.60

−11.03

15.04

−1.35

−2.12

15.37

***

0.38

3244.26

258.00

WTIT1

−27.71

−26.88

−25.48

−0.15

6.01

−22.26

9.24

***

−9.92

168.58

37.00

WTC

−2.83

−6.46

1.41

31.19

10.76

3.62

20.86

***

10.23

190.73

42.00

WTC-W

0.03

−0.36

0.41

0.92

−0.24

−3.85

0.85

***

−0.38

469.69

152.00

WTF1T1

−10.82

−11.26

−1.61

−2.93

8.78

−8.89

−2.93

***

−3.14

222.21

64.00

WTT1F2

4.60

−10.73

17.95

28.99

15.33

55.33

11.99

*

19.81

109.73

23.00

WT1E

35.90

31.72

31.76

23.72

24.68

8.24

24.46

***

25.77

11.73

114.42

  1. 1These animals served as reference group for the fixed effects analysis.
  2. 2Actual trait mean values by batch, corrected for gender effects.
  3. 3Mean (All), average trait value across all batches (n=192);
  4. 4S, maximum significance of an individual batch compared to reference group.
  5. 5CV (%)-within, mean within batch coefficient of variation combined across all batches;
  6. 6CV%-batch; coefficient of variation among batch means.