Enhanced tolerance to drought stress resulting from Caragana korshinskii CkWRKY33 in transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana

Background It is well known that WRKY transcription factors play important roles in plant growth and development, defense regulation and stress responses. Results In this study, a WRKY transcription factor, WRKY33, was cloned from Caragana korshinskii. A sequence structure analysis showed that it belonged to the Group-I type. Subcellular localization experiments in tobacco epidermal cells showed the presence of CkWRKY33 in the nucleus. Additionally, CkWRKY33 was overexpressed in Arabidopsis thaliana. A phenotypic investigation revealed that compared with wild-type plants, CkWRKY33-overexpressing transgenic plants had higher survival rates, as well as relative soluble sugar, proline and peroxidase contents, but lower malondialdehyde contents, following a drought stress treatment. Conclusions This suggested that the overexpression of CkWRKY33 led to an enhanced drought-stress tolerance in transgenic A. thaliana. Thus, CkWRKY33 may act as a positive regulator involved in the drought-stress responses in Caragana korshinskii. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12863-021-00965-4.


Background
Plants undergo different kinds of environmental stresses, such as exposure to drought, salt, cold and others during their whole life cycles [1]. Stresses usually affect plant growth, survival and yield. Plants have developed diverse adaptive mechanisms to respond to various abiotic stresses during the long-term evolutionary process [2]. Most of these mechanisms are controlled by networks regulated by transcription factors (TFs) [3]. TFs are proteins that can specifically bind to cis-acting elements, and regulate the expression of downstream target genes [4].
WRKY TFs, which are named for their highly conserved WRKY domains, form a large family in higher plants and play important roles in many physiological processes [5,6]. Many WRKY TFs have been discovered in various plants. For example, 74 WRKY members exist in the Arabidopsis genome, 109 in the rice genome, 57 in the cucumber genome, 105 in the willow genome, and 46 in the rape genome [6][7][8][9][10]. On the basis of the number of WRKY domains and the structural characteristics of zinc fingers, all the members of the WRKY TF family are divided into three categories, I, II and III [5]. Group-I members generally contain two WRKY domains in the N-and C-terminal end, and its zinc finger structure type is C2H2 (cx4-5-c-× 22-23-h-× 1-h). Members include such as AtWRKY54, AcWRKY9 and OsWRKY96. Group-II members contain only one WRKY domain structure, and the structure of the zinc finger is the same as in Group-I. Members include such as GmWRKY21, AtWRKY40 and AcWRKY3. Most of the WRKY TFs belong to this type. Group-III members contain only one WRKY domain structure, and the zinc finger structure is the C2-HC (C-X7-C-X23-H-X1-C) type. Members include such as AtWRKY4, AtWRKY54 and VlWRKY48 [11,12].
WRKYs are involved in the drought-stress responses of plants. For example, WRKY54 and WRKY70 negatively regulate osmotic stress in Arabidopsis, and these two genes are involved in the regulation of plant growth and response to drought [13,14]. The overexpression of OsWRKY11 under the control of the HSP101 promoter leads to the enhancement of drought resistance, which is manifested as slower leaf withering and higher survival rates of green plants [15]. The overexpression of OsWRKY45 and OsWRKY72 can change the drought tolerance of Arabidopsis plants, which may be related to the induction of abscisic acid/stress-related genes [16,17]. The knockout mutant oswrky47 was highly sensitive to drought, resulting in decreased yield, while the over-expressed mutant of OsWRKY47 was more resistant to drought [18]. A transcriptome analysis showed that the expression levels of WRKY16, WRKY59 and WRKY61 are up-regulated after drought treatments in common wheat, and these genes may participate in drought-stress response [19].
Caragana korshinskii Kom. is a leguminous shrub that is widely distributed across desert habitats with gravellike, sandy, and saline soils in Asia and Africa. C. korshinskii has highly developed roots and a strong tolerance to abiotic stress [20]. Studies on C. korshinskii have mainly focused on biological characteristics, physiological changes and anatomical structure [21]. Relatively few drought-related genes have been identified in C. korshinskii, such as CkLEA1 [22], CkWRKY1 [23] and CKNCED1 [24]. Most of the genes were cloned using PCR-based methods without any gene function analyses. In our previous study, we used RNA-Seq and a de novo assembly method to produce a transcriptome library of C. korshinskii Kom [25]. Then, we identified the drought-resistance genes by comparing two digital gene expression libraries, and several drought-related genes have been identified. Based on the bioinformatics analysis, here, we cloned the WRKY33 gene and analyzed its gene structure and type in the C. korshinskii genome. Then, the drought-resistant phenotypes and physiological indices of the Arabidopsis transgenic plants were determined to verify the CkWRKY33 gene's function, which could play an important role in C. korshinskii growing under drought-stress conditions.

CkWRKY33 cloning and sequence analysis
In our previous study, we used 1 month old seedling of C. korshinskii Kom. to do drought treatment, and then we did RNA-seq and de novo assembly (BioSample: SAMN03121496). The results showed that there were 440 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) between drought and control plants, and among the DEGs, 39 unigenes showed up-regulated expression after drought treatment. After comparing with the database, we named one unigene, com66203 as CkWRKY33.
The full-length cDNA of CkWRKY33 was obtained from total RNA extracted from drought-stressed C. korshinskii Kom. leaves using RT-PCR. The nucleotide sequence of the CkWRKY33 gene is 2075 bp in length, consisting of a 23-bp 5′ untranslated region, an 1614 bp open reading frame (ORF) and a 345-bp 3′ UTR. The ORF encodes a putative 537-amino acid protein. Sequence alignments between CkWRKY33 and other plant WRKY proteins indicated that the amino acid sequences of these proteins share a high similarity. The sequence identity between CkWRKY33 and the other proteins in the analysis ranged from 39 to 85% (Fig. 1). A multiple sequence alignment analysis revealed that CkWRKY33 contains two putative WRKY domains followed by a C2H2-type zinc-finger motif, a putative nuclear localization signal and a short conserved structural motif (C-motif), indicating that CkWRKY33 belongs to Group-I of the WRKY family ( Fig. 1).
A phylogenetic tree was constructed to investigate the evolutionary relationships among CkWRKY33 and other WRKY proteins. As shown in Fig. 2, CkWRKY33 showed a close relationship with AtWRKY33 in Arabidopsis, WRKY24 in rice and WRKY115 in maize. These proteins participate in plant response to abiotic stresses [26,27]. Thus, these proteins having high homology levels among different species, may share some similar functions.

Subcellular localization of CkWRKY33
To determine the subcellular localization of CkWRKY33, the ORF of CkWRKY33 without the termination codon was fused to the 5′ end of the GFP reporter gene under the control of the CaMV35S promoter. The recombinant construct and the GFP vector were independently introduced into tobacco epidermal cells. Confocal imaging showed that the 35 s-CkWRKY33-GFP fusion protein was exclusively localized in the nuclear. By contrast, tobacco epidermal cells transformed with the 35 s-GFP vector alone displayed fluorescence throughout the entire cell, demonstrating that CkWRKY33 is a nuclear localized protein (Fig. 3).

Overexpression of CkWRKY33 enhances tolerance to mannitol stress
The full-length cDNA of CkWRKY33 under the control of the CaMV35S promoter was transformed into Arabidopsis.
After positive transformants were screened and selfcrossed, the seeds of T 2 transgenic homozygous and wild-type (WT) lines were sown on normal 1/2MS medium and 1/2MS medium supplemented with mannitol. On 1/2MS solid medium, the growth of transgenic lines was generally similar to that of WT, with no obvious change in root length. Under mannitoltreatment conditions, the seedlings of both the transgenic and WT plants grew weakly, the rosette leaves turned yellow, and the root lengths became shorter as the mannitol concentration increased. With both 50 mM and 100 mM mannitol treatments, the root lengths of transgenic plants were longer than those of WT plants (Fig. 4). Thus, the root length of Arabidopsis was changed by mannitol stress, and the CkWRKY33 gene may have effect on the mannitol resistance of the plant. Overexpression of CkWRKY33 enhances the tolerance to drought stresses In addition to the mannitol-stress treatment, the seeds of three transgenic and WT lines were sown in soil. After these plants had grown for 21 d under normal conditions, watering was stopped. After 15 d of the natural drought treatment, most leaves of WT plants had lost their green color and turned yellow, or even died. The transgenic plants showed slight yellowing and curling at the leaf tips and dehydration; however, they grew well and had a normal phenotype. After rehydration, WT plants showed complete wilting and dehydration, while the leaves of transgenic lines showed a low degree of atrophy and good growth. Compared with under drought-stress conditions, the leaves of transgenic plants became tender after 3 d of rehydration, indicating that transgenic plants were strongly resilient after rehydration (Fig. 5a).
The survival rate of WT was 8.33%, which was lower than any of the three transgenic lines. The survival rate of the three lines was 80% on average. Thus, the expression of the transformed CkWRKY33 increased the drought resistance of transgenic plants (Fig. 5b).
A qRT-PCR experiment was used to analyze the expression patterns of CkWRKY33 in transgenic plants before and after drought treatment. The relative expression level revealed that compared with before drought treatment, the CkWRKY33 was highly induced expression by drought treatment in transgenic plants (Fig. 5c). After the drought treatment, the gene expressed 3 to 5 times more in transgenic plants than before drought treatment. After rehydration, the gene's expression level in the transgenic plants decreased. Thus, that expression of the WRKY TF may improve the tolerance of transgenic Arabidopsis to drought stress.

Changes in physiological traits under stress conditions
The leaf water loss rates of WT and transgenic plants were detected. The water loss rate increased as the processing time increased for all the plants. It was greater in WT than in transgenic plants (Fig. 6a). After 1 h, the water loss rate of the WT was 27.8% and the rates of the transgenic lines ranged from 11.8 to 20.5%. After a 12 h treatment, the water loss rates of all the transgenic lines were less than 86%, while that of the WT was as high as 92.3% (Fig. 6a). This indicated that the transgenic lines had lower water loss rates and stronger drought-tolerance levels.   The values of four physiological traits, soluble sugar content, malondialdehyde (MDA) content, proline content and peroxidase (POD) activity, were determined for the drought-treated transgenic plants. The soluble sugar content of each transgenic plant line was higher than that of the WT. The highest value for the transgenic plants was 23.70 mg/g and the lowest value was 16.08 mg/g. The MDA content was lower in transgenic plants than in WT, and the lowest value among the transgenic lines was 2.32 nmol/g. Thus, as the MDA content in the transgenic plants decreased, the damage to plant cell membranes decreased and the drought resistance increased. The proline content was higher in transgenic plants than in WT after drought stress, and the POD content followed the same trend (Fig. 6b-e).

Discussion
WRKY TFs play important roles in plant responses to biotic and abiotic stresses. However, there is limited research regarding the gene functions of WRKY TFs in the desert tree C. korshinskii Kom. In this study, we isolated the CkWRKY33 gene from C. korshinskii Kom. The gene structure and evolutionary relationships were analyzed, and then, gene function was confirmed using a transgenic approach. The current study is important in elucidating WRKY protein-regulated responses to abiotic stress in C. korshinskii Kom..
According to the transcriptome assembly sequence, the CDS sequence of CkWRKY33 was cloned. Based on the high similarity between the CkWRKY33 protein and other WRKY proteins obtained from Arabidopsis, Cicer arietinum, Glycine max and Vigna angularis, we confirmed that the gene isolated from C. korshinskii Kom. is a WRKY gene and that belonged to Group-I. The results of subcellular localization of 35 s-CkWRKY33-GFP showed that the GFP signal was located in the nucleus, which suggested that CkWRKY33 actually function in the nucleus. The phylogenetic analysis of the CkWRKY33 sequence, together with the orthologous WRKY TFs from different plant species, such as Arabidopsis, maize, and Glycine max, revealed a phylogenetic tree having two distinct clades (Fig. 2). WRKY33 has evolved substantially after the divergence of dicots and monocots from their last common ancestor [28].
Until now, there were some researches involving the functions of WRKY33 in different species, including in Arabidopsis [27], oilseed rape [29] and maize [30]. In Arabidopsis, the over-expression of WRKY33 was sufficient to increase Arabidopsis NaCl tolerance, and the same function was found in maize. In oilseed rape, over-expression of WRKY33 could increase the Sclerotinia resistance. To investigate the mechanisms by which CkWRKY33 confers abiotic stress tolerance, we performed several experiments to monitor the phenotypic and physiological changes associated with drought responses. Mannitol is a sugar alcohol that is associated with plant stress resistance and is found in bacteria, fungi, and many higher plants [31,32]. In this study, it was used to simulate natural drought-treatment conditions. Using mannitol stress, the phenotypic and root length changes of the transgenic plants could be observed. Thus, this provided an indicator system for the identification of drought resistance in C. korshinskii Kom..
POD activity, as well as soluble sugar, proline and MDA contents, are generally important physiological indicators of stress resistance in plants [33,34]. In this study, soluble sugar, MDA and proline contents, as well as the POD activity, in WT and transgenic plants were determined under drought-stress conditions. Soluble sugar has a strong hydration capability, and its content increases under stress, which aids cells in holding water and preventing further damage [35]. The soluble sugar contents in the transgenic plants were greater than in that in WT plants after exposure to drought stress. In addition to the soluble sugar contents, the proline contents in the transgenic plants were also greater than that in WT plants after exposure to drought stress. The result was consistent with a previous study [36]. As a member of the antioxidant enzyme defense system, a high POD activity can reduce the accumulation of ROS, weaken the damage to cells and improve the stress resistance of plants. In this study, after drought-stress exposure, the POD activity levels in transgenic plants were greater than in WT plants. This was also found in other species. For example, TaWRKY10 overexpression enhances drought stress, which may be caused by the decrease in ROS accumulation in tobacco [37]. MDA is a product of membrane lipid peroxidation, and its content is used to evaluate the tolerance of plants under stress conditions. Thus, it is used as a marker of lipid peroxidation and, therefore, of membrane damage [38]. We observed a lower MDA content in 35S::CkWRKY33 transgenic seedlings than in WT after exposure to drought stress. In conclusion, these analyses suggested that the over-expression of the CkWRKY33 gene in Arabidopsis increased the content of these substances, which may result in improved drought tolerance in transgenic plants.

Conclusion
In this study, a WRKY transcription factor, WRKY33 was cloned from the desert tree, Caragana korshinskii, which has the characters of high tolerance to abiotic stress. Gene structural analysis showed that it belonged to the Group-I type. Subcellular localization experiments showed the presence of CkWRKY33 in the nucleus. Then CkWRKY33 was over-expressed in the model plant Arabidopsis. When the over-expressed transgenic plants and WT were treated with drought stress, the transgenic lines showed higher survival rates, as well as relative soluble sugar, proline and peroxidase contents, but lower malondialdehyde contents. All the results mean that CkWRKY33 may act as a positive regulator involved in the drought-stress responses in Caragana korshinskii.

Plant materials
The seeds of C. korshinskii Kom. (http://www.iplant.cn/ info/Caragana%20korshinskii?t=foc) were collected by Dr. Xinwu Pei from the Minqin Shasheng Botanical Garden in Gansu Province, China. The seeds were sown in a greenhouse and used as a source of material to clone WRKY33. A. thaliana ecotype Columbia-0 was used for the overexpression experiments and the WT and transgenic A. thaliana lines were grown at 22°C, 70% relative humidity and a long-day photoperiod (16-h light/8-h dark).

CkWRKY33 cloning and sequence analysis
Total RNA was extracted from the leaves using the ZR Plant RNA MiniPrep Kit (ZYMO RESEARCH, Beijing, China), following the manufacturer's protocol. First-strand cDNA was synthesized using PrimeScript™ RTase (TaKaRa Biotechnology, Dalian, China) according to the manufacturer's instructions. A CkWRKY33 cDNA corresponding to the predicted ORF was amplified by PCR using the gene-specific primers F1 (5′-ATGACTATGG ATGATCATAACTG-3′) and R1 (5′-TTAGAAGTCC TTTGACATAAAT-3′). The PCR product was cloned into the pEasy-T1 cloning vector (Transgen, Beijing, China), and was then sequenced. Amino acid sequences of homologous WRKY33 proteins from other plant species were obtained from the NCBI database (https://www.ncbi. nlm.nih.gov)using BLASTP. A multiple sequence alignment of the deduced protein sequences and phylogenetic analyses were carried out using the DNAMAN software.

Subcellular localization of CkWRKY33
Using in-fusion homologous recombination technology, the CkWRKY33 full-length DNA sequence fragment was inserted into a CaMV 35 s-GFP vector constructed previously by our laboratory to obtain the recombinant fusion construct 35 s-CkWRKY33-GFP. Then the new recombinant vector (35 s-CkWRKY33-GFP) and the control (35 s-GFP) were independently delivered to competent cells of Agrobacterium tumefaciens LBA4404 using the freeze-thaw approach. After the positive bacterial clones were identified, yeast extract peptone medium was employed to cultivate these clones, as well as the mRFP-AHL22 strain conserved by the laboratory as a localization marker [39]. The medium was supplemented with the appropriate antibiotics, 5 mM MES (Ph = 5.7) and 200 μM acetosyringone. When the bacterial solution's concentrations reached OD600 = 0.6-1.0, they were centrifuged at 8000 rpm for 6 min to harvest the bacterial sediment. The sediment was washed with buffer containing 10 mM MgCl 2 , 10 mM MES twice and resuspended in the buffer above supplemented with 200 μM acetosyringone. The suspension's concentrations were adjusted to OD600 = 0.5-0.6, and then, it was placed at 4°C in the darkness for 3-4 h. Before injecting the Nicotiana benthamiana leaves, the suspension of mRFP-AHL22 was added at a 1:1 ratio and mixed well. The mixture was infiltrated into tobacco leaves using a syringe. The GFP signals in leaves were observed under a laser scanning confocal microscope after 24-48 h.
Generation of transgenic A. thaliana plants overexpressing the CkWRKY33 gene The coding sequence of CkWRKY33 (with EcoRI and XmaI sites added to its 5′ and 3′ ends, respectively) was amplified from pEasy-T1-CkWRKY33 using gene-specific primers F2 (5′-ACTGACGTAAGGGATGACGCACA ATGACTATGGATGATCATAACTG-3′) and R2 (5′-GTTGCTAGCACTATTGCCAAAAA TTAGAAGTCC TTTGACATAAAT-3′). It was then inserted in the plant over-expression vector, 35sRED using the in-fusion method, and called 35S::CkWRKY33. A. tumefaciens EHA105 harboring the 35S::CkWRKY33 construct was used to transform Arabidopsis by the floral-dip method [40]. T 0 seeds were harvested and then the positive transgenic seeds were selected using hand-held green fluorescent flashlight through a red filter in the dark. If the seeds with red fluorescence were observed, the seeds were confirmed as the positive transgenic seeds. Then these positive seeds were sowed and self-pollinated until the T 2 generation. Finally, the T 2 homozygous lines were generated and used for all the subsequent experiments.

Drought stress treatments of transgenic A. thaliana lines
To test the effects of drought stresses, 5-d-old transgenic and WT seedlings grown on 1/2MS medium plates were transferred to plates containing 1/2MS medium, or 1/ 2MS medium supplemented with either 50 mM or 100 mM mannitol. WT and transgenic Arabidopsis seeds were planted in cultivation pots at a density of four seeds per pot, using a total of 24 seeds. Three replicates were set and cultured in a greenhouse under 16 h light / 8 h dark conditions. After 3 weeks of plant growth, a natural drought treatment was carried out. WT plants were used as the controls. After the WT plants showed signs of death, all the plants were rehydrated for 2-3 d to determine their survival rates and the phenotypes of transgenic and WT plants were recorded.
To determine the water loss rate, 10 leaves were detached from 4-week-old transgenic and WT plants and immediately weighed. The samples were then placed on dry filter paper at a relative humidity of 40-45% at room temperature and weighed over a time course. The water loss rate was calculated as previously described [41].

Gene expression analysis by quantitative real-time RT-PCR
Samples were taken from 3-week-old WT and transgenic A. thaliana seedlings after 15 d of drought treatment and 3 d of rehydration.
Total RNA was extracted from Arabidopsis leaves using an RNA prep plant kit (Tiangen Biotech.,Beijing, China) following the manufacturer's protocols. Firststrand cDNA was synthesized using PrimeScript™RTase (TaKaRa Biotechnology,Beijing, China) according to the manufacturer's instructions. The quantitative real-time RT-PCR (qRT-PCR) analysis was conducted using SYBR green (TaKaRa Biotechnology) and an ABI7500 realtime RT-PCR instrument with the following thermal profile: 95°C for 30 s, 40 cycles of 95°C for 5 s, and 60°C for 30 s. Each reaction was performed in triplicate for each of the three biologically replicated sets of cDNA samples. To perform the melt-curve analysis, the following program was added after the 40 PCR cycles: 95°C for 15 s, followed by a constant increase from 60°C to 95°C. A. thaliana Actin 1 (TAIR: AT2G37620, https:// www.arabidopsis.org/servlets/TairObject?id=31592&type= locus) was used as the reference gene. Primers used for qRT-PCR are listed in Additional file 1. Relative gene expression values were determined by using the 2 -ΔΔCt method [42] The experiment was repeated three times.

Measurements of the soluble sugar, MDA and proline contents and POD activity levels
The values of four physiological traits, soluble sugar content, MDA content, proline content and POD activity level, were determined for the drought-treated transgenic plants. Arabidopsis leaves were collected during the drought treatment. Each trait was determined using the appropriate kit, following the manufacturer's instructions (Solarbio, Beijing, China).