Skip to main content

Table 2 Candidate model set for NMDR study.

From: Genotyping errors in a calibrated DNA register: implications for identification of individuals

Model

Fixed

Rand

σ

AIC

p

SD(p)

CV(p)

W

M1

LOCUS + YEAR

IND

1.35

295.7

0.0774

0.0214

0.28

5.76e-1

M2

YEAR

IND

1.24

297.5

0.0243

0.0045

0.19

2.34e-1

M3

LAB + LOCUS

IND

1.43

299.3

0.0514

  

9.52e-2

 

Lab1

   

0.0823

0.0242

0.29

 
 

Lab2

   

0.0185

0.0088

0.48

 
 

Lab4

   

0.0102

0.0089

0.87

 

M4

LAB

IND

1.32

301.0

0.0162

  

4.07e-2

 

Lab1

   

0.0261

0.0045

0.17

 
 

Lab2

   

0.0054

0.0024

0.44

 
 

Lab4

   

0.0029

0.0025

0.86

 

M5

LOCUS + YEAR

-

-

303.1

0.0768

0.0239

0.29

1.42e-2

M6

LOCUS + YEAR

MP:IND

1.22

303.5

0.0771

0.0237

0.33

1.17e-2

M7

YEAR

-

-

303.6

0.024

0.0046

0.2

1.11e-2

M8

YEAR

MP:IND

1.13

304.0

0.0242

0.0047

0.2

9.08e-3

M9

LAB + LOCUS

-

-

307.1

0.0511

  

1.92e-3

 

Lab1

   

0.0822

0.0263

0.32

 
 

Lab2

   

0.0182

0.0118

0.65

 
 

Lab4

   

0.0094

0.0097

1.04

 

M10

LAB + LOCUS

MP:IND

1.31

307.2

0.0516

  

1.83e-3

 

Lab1

   

0.0828

0.0405

0.49

 
 

Lab2

   

0.0193

0.0172

0.89

 
 

Lab4

   

0.0102

0.0131

1.28

 

M11

LAB

-

-

307.5

0.016

  

1.58e-3

 

Lab1

   

0.0259

0.0048

0.19

 
 

Lab2

   

0.0056

0.0032

0.58

 
 

Lab4

   

0.0028

0.0031

1.08

 

M12

LAB

MP:IND

1.20

307.9

0.0162

  

1.29e-3

 

Lab1

   

0.0261

0.038

0.15

 
 

Lab2

   

0.0056

0.081

1.44

 
 

Lab4

   

0.0028

0.062

2.15

 

M13

LOCUS

IND

1.52

308.3

0.0513

0.0129

0.25

1.06e-3

M14

-

IND

1.41

309.9

0.016

0.0026

0.17

4.75e-4

M15

LOCUS

MP:IND

1.50

318.3

0.0523

0.0057

0.11

7.12e-6

M16

-

MP:IND

1.36

319.1

0.0162

0.0055

0.36

4.78e-6

M17

LOCUS

-

-

319.5

0.0512

0.0156

0.3

3.91e-6

M18

-

-

-

319.8

0.016

0.0030

0.2

3.37e-6

  1. Model fit and estimated error rates for different covariate models sorted according to the AIC score (column five). "σ" contains the standard deviations of the random effects. The values in "p" are the probabilities that an error occurs at locus GATA417 in year 2001. Whenever LAB is included in the model, weighted means and laboratory specific error rates are given (Lab 1, Lab 2, Lab 4). "SD(p)" and "CV(p)" are the bootstrap based standard deviations and coefficients of variance of p. The column "W" contains the Akaike weights of the models.